Editorial decision

From my point of view, the most concerning comment in Chirigati’s review is that he attempted to create an account on the web platform, failed to receive a confirmation email, and was unable to log in. At this time (8 April 2019), the site at https://corr-root.org still seems broken: it has an expired certificate and won’t immediately load unless a visitor overrides the browser's security measures. I also tried to register received no verification email, and cannot log in. The platform also shows just 6 users and 21 records. So, even though the concepts presented in the paper are interesting, and reviewers allow for a revised version to be published, the platform is still immature and thus seems not ready for a formal publication. We encourage the authors to work on fixing the site and building community. We would be willing to consider the paper again once the project appears more stable. If and when the authors are ready for the work to be considered again for CiSE RR Track, the following comments should be addressed.